85. Everyday Essentialism: On Differentiating “Brands” from “Suppliers”

We all know that there’s a kind of essentialism that happens in conversations about sustainable fashion (and beyond). It’s shorthand that artificially groups together very diverse groups of people and lumps them according to a single or several defining features. This episode is an open… [...]
13 Dec 2022
00:30:24
Manufactured
Manufactured
85. Everyday Essentialism: On Differentiating “Brands” from “Suppliers”
/

We all know that there’s a kind of essentialism that happens in conversations about sustainable fashion (and beyond). It’s a shorthand that artificially groups together very diverse groups of people and lumps them according to a single or several defining features. This episode is an open discussion of two such terms: “brand” and “supplier.”

The discussion brings together people that have each, in their own ways, inhabited “gray zones” between these two terms or defied stereotypes about what these terms colloquially signify:

  • Sharon Tsang, founder of Anew Studios a boutique sustainable sourcing and consulting company catering to small and medium sized fashion brands. Sharon’s parents are from Hong Kong and she currently lives in Hong Kong, but she has also spent significant time in Canada.  Her entry point into the world of fashion was initially on the brand side in Canada, though she now occupies an in-between space.
  • Manufactured Podcast Co-Founder Jessie Li. As regular listeners will know, Jessie is originally Chinese, though currently based in Cambodia. She started her career working for a third-party inspection company in China (listen to her talk about that chapter here). She then went on to work on the brand side as a merchandiser for buying office in China (listen to her talk about that chapter here) before ultimately working on the supplier side for a factory in Cambodia – which is where we met.
  • Then there’s me. I’ve only ever worked on the supplier side, as a garment factory manager. I’m a white woman born to Dutch and American parents; my educational training is very “Western” – I have a degree in human rights from a university in London.

We start the discussion by sharing what comes to mind when we hear the term “brand” and the term “supplier.” Though we each have different answers, we all struggled to find adequate technical differentiators.

This led us to the question: if distinguishing between a “brand” and a “supplier” is, from a technical perspective, so difficult, then why are these terms to central to the sustainable fashion conversation? Which then led us into a conversation about power. We tentatively conclude that brands (and retailers) are lumped together because they are in a position of power. Suppliers, in contrast, are not. What gives brands their power? Is it the nature of the commercial relationship? Or something deeper? Like history? And their ability to tell stories that resonate with particular groups of people from particular parts of the world?

 

Want to dig deeper ?

The Danger of a Single Story – a Ted talk by Chimamanda Ngozi Adiche.

How Racism Shapes Fashion’s Approach to Sustainability – Kim van der Weerd

 A (very) brief intro to strategic essentialism

Recent Episodes

92. How it’s made: On Cotton with Rajeev Baruah

92. How it’s made: On Cotton with Rajeev Baruah

On this episode we’re taking a look at cotton value chains in the Indian context with Rajeev Baruah, who has worked in cotton for decades. Though his background is originally in agriculture and tea, his cotton journey started with a spinning facility back in the 90s on a mission to work with organic cotton farmers – something that, at the time, was unheard of. In the years since, he’s gone on to work in a number of different roles with different stakeholders across the value chain. Rajeev gives Kim an in-depth look at the steps that go into growing, harvesting, ginning, and spinning cotton, who the commercial actors are, and what their incentives might be within the Indian context.

read more
91. How it’s made: On Garment Finishing with Rita Castro & Dionísia Portela

91. How it’s made: On Garment Finishing with Rita Castro & Dionísia Portela

On this episode we’re exploring one of the final stages of production in apparel manufacturing with Rita Castro & Dionísia Portela from Confetil, a Portuguese garment manufacturer that has been supplying brands all over the world since 1960. Dionísia is Sustainability Manager and Rita is Sales and Commercial Manager for four of Confetil’s customers. They tell us more about the processes that give our clothes the final look and feel that brands aim for, from solid T-shirts to those with graphic patterns or vintage looks, different types of dyes and dyeing processes, and the sustainability of these finishing processes.

read more
90. How it’s made: On Silk with Hilmond Hui

90. How it’s made: On Silk with Hilmond Hui

To understand the process, benefits and barriers within regenerative sericulture, we go back to Kim’s conversation from November 2021 with Hilmond Hui, Vice President of international clothing enterprise PFG and its subset Bombyx. Hilmond tells us more about Bombyx, which was formed in 2018 with a focus on regenerative silk production and transforming the way silk is produced, traded and consumed. Their Nanchong Ka Fung (NCKF) facility is located in the northeast of China’s Sichuan province, and they’re on a mission to do everything from dirt to fabric and beyond.

read more